MultiShift
MultiShift

Home / Calculators / Rent vs. Buy Calculator

Rent vs. Buy Calculator

Determine whether it is financially smarter to buy a house or keep renting. Our interactive simulator projects mortgage interest, property taxes, HOA fees, home appreciation, and maintenance against renting while investing your down payment in index funds over a 15-year horizon.

Home Purchase Assumptions

$
%
%
%
$
%

Rental Assumptions

$
%
%
US HOUSING DECISION TOOL

Buying creates more long-term wealth!

Break-Even Horizon1 years
Point where buying pays off
Net Cost of Home Ownership$ 83,644
Payments minus home equity
Net Cost of Renting$ 146,929
Rent minus investment returns
Net Financial Wealth Advantage$ 63,285
Advantage for best option at year 7

In the United States, home ownership acts as forced savings and builds equity, but renting offers flexibility and frees capital to compound in the stock market.

Timeline Comparison by Year

YearNet Cost to BuyNet Cost to RentWinning Option
1º years$ 13,869$ 20,100Buy (+$ 6,231)
2º years$ 27,149$ 40,520Buy (+$ 13,371)
3º years$ 39,811$ 61,247Buy (+$ 21,436)
4º years$ 51,824$ 82,268Buy (+$ 30,444)
5º years$ 63,156$ 103,568Buy (+$ 40,412)
6º years$ 73,775$ 125,129Buy (+$ 51,354)
7º years$ 83,644$ 146,929Buy (+$ 63,285)
Report a problem

How it works

  1. Enter target home purchase price, down payment percentage, mortgage interest rate, and property tax.

  2. Provide monthly rent for a comparable home, anticipated rent inflation, and stock market investment returns.

  3. View the breakeven year, monthly outlay breakdown, and net worth trajectory comparison.

Frequently asked questions

How does the Rent vs. Buy calculation work?

It compares unrecoverable costs of homeownership (mortgage interest, property tax, HOA, maintenance, closing costs) against unrecoverable rent payments, while factoring in home appreciation and the opportunity cost of investing your down payment.

What is the typical breakeven period for buying in the US?

In most US housing markets, the breakeven timeline is between 4 and 7 years. Moving sooner often results in a net financial loss due to 6% broker commissions and closing costs.

Is this tool free?

Yes. The site is supported by ads, so you never pay or need to create an account.

Does it work on mobile?

Yes. The page adapts to your screen and does not require installing any app.